Revisiting my extensive music collection, one artist at a time

HALL & OATES Part 3 – They Did It In A Minute

Hall & Oates - X-StaticBy the time they released X-Static (1979), Daryl Hall & John Oates were two years removed from the mega success of their #1 single, “Rich Girl,” and with two subsequent commercially disappointing albums under their belt, they had to be wondering if their hit-making days were behind them. Like the previous album’s “It’s A Laugh,” X-Static included one Top 20 single (“Wait For Me”) that was quickly forgotten until an outstanding live version was included on a best-of compilation a few years later. For this album, the duo teamed up once again with producer David Foster, who did an excellent job on its under-appreciated predecessor, Along The Red Ledge (which I discussed in my previous post).

X-Static is also notable for the initial appearance of several musicians who would play a huge part in their early-‘80s success: guitarist G.E. Smith (who later gained notoriety as the bandleader for Saturday Night Live), drummer Jerry Marotta (best known for Hall & Oates Photo (from X-Static)his work on Peter Gabriel’s early solo albums), saxophonist Charlie DeChant (who continues to deliver memorable sax melodies for the duo all these years later) and bassist John Siegler. These gentlemen would form the core of the Hall & Oates band for the next several years, with a few later lineup changes that I will mention below. Their first recorded collaboration features one minor classic, some very good songs and a number of generic tracks which indicated that they didn’t have the consistently strong songwriting that was just around the corner. Much of the album focuses on dance rhythms and new wave textures, an approach they would hone to perfection on the next record.

The Essential:
♪ “Wait For Me” – An incredible ballad by Hall which cracked the Top 20. I love the soaring melodic guitar work by G.E. Smith. The instrumentation isn’t as organic as it would be on the live version that appeared on their Rock ‘N Soul Part 1 compilation, but even in this slightly synthetic setting it’s still a gorgeous song.

Other Notable Tracks:

  • “The Woman Comes And Goes” – A precursor to their slicker ‘80s sound, with a sparse syncopated rhythm, bouncy piano & blasting sax accents. The only thing missing is a killer hook, something they would soon deliver on a regular basis. I like the slightly off-kilter, manic-yet-controlled energy, tight harmonies & guitar stabs.
  • “Portable Radio” – With the thumping beat, bubbling bass line and synth washes, this could be the theme for a forgotten movie or TV show of its era. The chorus is the catchiest part, and I like how they alternate lead vocal lines throughout the song. It was very nearly an “essential” track but it’s a little bit over-the-top.
  • “Number One” – Has a new wave/reggae vibe and a punk-ish energy. It might be slightly derivative of some other contemporary artists like Elvis Costello, The (English) Beat and Joe Jackson but there are great performances all around, and Hall’s voice is forceful & powerful.
  • “Intravino” – A goofy & fun dance/new wave tune with a driving groove and a nice hook at “Wine, wine, I need intravino.” Silly? Yes, but fun and super catchy too.
  • “Time’s Up (Alone Tonight)” – Of the two studio outtakes included on the expanded CD version I own, this is the one I prefer. It’s too bad it got overlooked, as the slightly funky groove and airtight arrangement were a perfect fit for the next album, and would have been a standout track on X-Static.

With three relatively unsuccessful albums in a row, I can’t imagine many people were predicting the massive success that was to follow. Beginning with Voices (1980), Hall & Oates Hall & Oates - Voices (Original Cover)pretty much took over the airwaves for much of that decade, and it was the album that solidified their position as great songwriters & performers, and not just those two guys who had a few hits in the ‘70s. Because they were so prolific for the next few years, many people believe that Voices is the album that contained all their big hits of that era. The fact is that the three albums that followed sold more copies & charted higher, and two of those three contained more Top 10 hits than Voices. In my opinion, though, it features the strongest batch of songs, with 8 of its 11 tracks deserving special mention. None of the albums that followed were as consistent from start-to-finish. It’s worth noting that this is their first self-produced effort, and its success must have been a huge validation for them as singers, songwriters, bandleaders & producers. Anyone who is dismissive of Hall & Oates, especially their ‘80s output, should really give this musically diverse album a listen with an open mind. It’s really that good.

Hall & Oates - Voices (CD Cover)The Essentials:
♪ “United State” – The title is a clever play on words that refers to a relationship, set to a peppy rocker that would have been perfect for radio in 1980. I’m not sure why no one at the record company thought to release it as a single. The melody at “When the light is gone from your eyes, and re-entry may be denied, do I want to expatriate or…live in the united state” is especially strong.

♪ “Kiss On My List” – Love it or hate it, this is a classic example of ‘80s pop perfection. I was 14 when this song was all over radio and I hated it, especially the too-cute-for-its-own-good title, but within a few years my opinion completely changed and I’ve loved it ever since. It’s sparsely produced, expertly sung, perfectly arranged and features another great melodic solo from G.E. Smith. There are so many reasons this was the first of five #1 hits they would score in that decade.
♪ “You Make My Dreams” – I love that off-kilter keyboard pattern in the intro, and the rest of the song is another example of pop excellence. The lead & backing vocals are incredible, and the bridge makes it even stronger: “Listen to this…I’m down on my daydreams…”
♪ “Everytime You Go Away” – This may be best known via the #1 hit version by British singer Paul Young in 1985, and even though the original isn’t quite as radio-friendly, it’s yet another brilliant Daryl Hall ballad. I love the soulful Stax-esque organ during the intro, giving it an immediate soulful-yet-sacred vibe.
♪ “Diddy Doo Wop (I Hear The Voices)” – Of all the memorable melodies throughout the Hall & Oates albums I’ve revisited this past week, no song worked its way into my brain quite like this one. The verses feature a pulsing bass groove, stabbing guitar (influenced by The Police’s Andy Summers, perhaps) and a winning vocal from Hall (“Oh I hear the voices deep inside”), while the choruses shift to a classic doo-wop rhythm with wonderful group voices, pointing the way to Billy Joel’s An Innocent Man a few years later. This is an interesting blend of genres and an inspired choice to close out the album.

Other Notable Tracks:

  • “How Does It Feel To Be Back” – Oates delivered this excellent album opener (and first Top 40 single from Voices); a tight, sparse melodic new wave rocker. I hear a similarity to Rick Springfield, who would score his first big hit a year later, with hints of Bruce Springsteen in the anthemic singing. I love the backing harmonies at “How does it feel to be back in my arms again?”
  • “Gotta Lotta Nerve (Perfect Perfect)” – Begins with doo-wop vocals set to a sparse drum beat before giving way to angular guitar stabs and an edgy punk-tinged attitude. The chorus is my favorite part, especially when Hall sings, “You gotta lotta nerve” and the various backing vocal responses to his lead.
  • “You’ve Lost That Lovin’ Feeling” – This cover of The Righteous Brothers’ #1 smash from the mid-‘60s is a perfect setting for their distinct vocals styles. Their version was actually my introduction to this song when I was 14. I don’t think I truly appreciated how good a song it is until I heard the original, but Hall & Oates add enough of their personalities to make this a worthwhile cover.

Hall & Oates - Private EyesVoices had a slow ascent up the charts throughout the second half of 1980, and by the time “Kiss On My List” topped the singles chart in early ’81, Hall & Oates were already in the studio recording its follow-up. Private Eyes (1981) doesn’t stray far from the template established by its predecessor, with only a few production flourishes added to their mix of rock, pop, soul & new wave. Once again they produced themselves, with the assistance of mixing engineer Neil Kernon, and the only notable lineup change was Mickey Curry (also known for his work with Bryan Adams) taking over on drums. Private Eyes is best known for three huge singles, including two #1’s and one Top 10, and those are the strongest songs on the album. Of the remaining eight tracks, only two show off their usual knack for memorable melodies and interesting arrangements, while the others are easily forgotten even after several listens. It’s hard to complain, though, when the good songs are this great, so Private Eyes is a qualified success.

Hall & Oates Photo (from Private Eyes)The Essentials:
♪ “Private Eyes” – Yet another example of perfect ‘80s pop music; a stomping blast of radio-friendly awesomeness. Features a super catchy melody with hand claps & synth hits, great vocals and clever lyrics about relationship trouble. It’s no surprise that this was another #1 smash, their second chart topper of 1981.
♪ “I Can’t Go For That (No Can Do)” – Perfect soulful pop, a la the Michael McDonald era of The Doobie Brothers, and a rare example of a song that reached #1 on the Pop, R&B and Dance charts. I love that proto-“Billie Jean” bass line, slick arrangement and the blend of synthetic sounds with organic instrumentation (especially Charlie DeChant’s classic sax solo). Simply gorgeous.
♪ “Did It In A Minute” – Too-clever-for-its-own-good title aside, this is an excellent pop song with typical ‘80s touches like the keyboard & drum sounds and the driving beat. I really like the pre-chorus (“Some things stay the same and some are due for change”) and the chorus itself is instantly memorable.

Other Notable Tracks:

  • “Tell Me What You Want” – After a 35-second intro of fade-in vocals, a guitar figure that recalls Rush’s “The Spirit Of Radio” emerges on top of a steady clip-clop beat. It has an XTC-esque quirkiness, shifting from offbeat verses to the straight-up “Tell me girl what you want” chorus to the fun “Tell me, tell me” backing vocals.
  • “Your Imagination” – I really like the slinky, slightly funky groove here, and that repeated 2-note riff (on synth-bass?) during the verses is a major hook. There are no instantly catchy melodies but it has a great vibe, a blazing sax solo and lots of little embellishments that add to the atmosphere.

Two years of non-stop hits led to their highest charting album, H2O (1982), which continued their chart dominance with three more Top 10 singles (including another #1). The Hall & Oates - H2Odistinctive-looking (and immensely talented) Tom “T-Bone” Wolk took over bass duties, a position he held until his death in 2010, while almost everyone else from the previous album (including co-producer Neil Kernon) returned. The hit-to-miss ratio is a little more successful here than it was on Private Eyes, and even though it’s not quite as consistent as Voices their winning streak continued with those three deserving hit singles and another three excellent album tracks. There are two versions of the album cover for H2O; the one with their sweaty profiles facing each other is a return to the questionable designs of some of their ‘70s albums, while the other one (with a close-up of sweat on skin, I believe) is a little more striking. I thought they had done a great job with the designs for Voices and Private Eyes, which are among their best album covers, so I suppose two out of three ain’t bad.

The Essentials:
♪ “Maneater” – Carried along by one of their trademark funky grooves, this #1 single is packed with a number of hooks, great imagery & a unique atmosphere. Wolk really delivers on bass, and DeChant’s sax is on fire. This is supremely ‘80s, in a good way.
♪ “One On One” – One of their most soulful songs with Hall delivering what may be his greatest vocal performance, effortlessly soaring in & out of falsetto. It reached the Top 10 on the Pop and R&B charts, and I’m surprised it didn’t go higher than that. An excellent example of minimal instrumentation with maximum effect.
♪ “Family Man” – Other than a couple of their ‘70s AM radio hits, I had little to no interest in Hall & Oates until I heard this song, another Top 10 hit. The heavy rhythm (nice work, Mickey Curry) and G.E. Smith’s cutting guitar sound immediately drew me in, and my entire perception of the group changed. Hall really inhabits the character of a devoted husband on the brink (“If you push me too far I just might”). It wasn’t until a few years later that I learned this was a cover of a Mike Oldfield song.

Hall & Oates - H2O (Alternate Cover)Other Notable Tracks:

  • “Open All Night” – I love the slow intense groove, very dramatic & powerful, and Hall’s vocals are incredibly powerful. I would call this a soulful semi-ballad. It’s not quite a classic, but a very good song that’s elevated by great performances.
  • “Italian Girls” – A non-charted single written by Oates. I never thought much of this song before, as it’s a little silly, but it won me over this past week. Musically it’s a typical ‘80s pop song, and Oates’ vocals are more in character (with a slight Italian accent at times). I like the “Faccia bello, cara mia” backing vocals.
  • “Go Solo” – For a duo where one guy wrote & sang the majority of their biggest songs, a track called “Go Solo” must have been slightly concerning to John Oates, even though it’s really about a romantic relationship. The verses aren’t very melodic, set to a slow yet insistent groove, but the choruses are where the song really shines: “If that ain’t enough, ain’t enough for you, go solo!” It’s a really nice way to close out the album, and I liked it more each time I played it.

It’s hard to imagine many compilations more effective at showcasing the truly best songs by a particular artist than Rock ‘N Soul Part 1 aka Greatest Hits (1983). Of the 12 songs included here, 9 were Top 10 hits (including 5 #1’s), while two of the previously unreleased tracks were new songs that became hits in their own right (both Top 10). Rarely do these add-Hall & Oates - Rock 'N Soul Part 1on tracks become as popular as the hits they’re complementing, but when you’re a group at the peak of its powers like Hall & Oates in the ‘80s, nearly everything you touch turns to gold (or platinum). The collection is weighted more heavily toward their ‘80s albums, but they wisely chose the three biggest hits from the ‘70s (“Sara Smile,” “She’s Gone” and “Rich Girl”) to give a broader view of their recording history. As I mentioned in the second post of my Gateway Compilations series, I’m not sure I would be the Hall & Oates fan I am today without Rock ‘N Soul Part 1.

The Essentials:
♪ “Say It Isn’t So” – Embracing the big ‘80s productions that were just becoming the industry standard, this song is slick, modern & huge-sounding with phenomenal vocals & tons of hooks. In spite of the synths, drum programming & various percussion sound effects, it somehow manages to sound soulful & natural. Even those “say it” backing vocals are nice touch.
♪ “Adult Education” – Features a funky groove with a slick ‘80s sonic sheen. From the killer rhythm track to the subject matter that struck a chord with me as a high school student at the time (“Believe it or not there’s life after high school”), everything about this song is a blast…even those of-their-time “oh yeah, oh yeah” female vocal chants. Mickey Curry’s huge drum sound is another selling point for me.

Other Notable Track:

  • “Wait For Me (Live)” – An already great song made even more powerful in concert, with Hall showing off his seemingly unlimited vocal range.

Hall & Oates Photo (circa 1983)

I want to give special attention to their contribution to my yearly holiday music listening with their faithful rendition of Bobby Helms’ 1950s standard, “Jingle Bell Rock.” The single has Hall handling lead vocals on one side and Oates on the other side, with the same musical accompaniment, and the promotional music video is silly, campy fun (although I don’t know if I’ll ever get the image of G.E. Smith as the guitar-playing granny out of my head). For your listening & viewing pleasure, I present that video here:

There’s something inspiring about hearing an artist in their absolute prime, as both Daryl Hall & John Oates were writing, performing & singing as well as they ever would during this period. I was a thick-headed teenager when they re-emerged as hit-makers in the early-‘80s but I’m glad I opened my eyes & ears soon enough to appreciate them in their heyday. I’m sure there are still people, mostly die-hard rock & roll fans, who dismiss their music as fluffy pop, but they offer so much more than that…during the period covered in this post and throughout their recording career. Please let me know how you feel about their early-‘80s commercial peak. Thank you.


16 comments on “HALL & OATES Part 3 – They Did It In A Minute

  1. Ian Balentine
    October 2, 2014

    …and this is when I first came in. I always loved Kiss On my Lost, although it took me decades to admit it publicly. It seems as if their album covers got better during this period (although I’m not crazy about H2O… A little too “Rocky IV” for me). Nile never a superman, this is the era I’m most familiar with. I’ll wager the majority are as well, but I’m really anxious to delve deeper!


    • Ian Balentine
      October 2, 2014

      “On My List”. Why no editing buttons? Damn.


      • Obviously I knew what you were referring to, but I know what you mean about the lack of an edit button once you leave a comment. The proof-reader in me hates when I miss a spelling error before posting a comment.


    • Hi Ian. Thanks for admitting your love of this era of their career, even if you were in the closet about it for years. I’m sure my friends & I mocked Hall & Oates between ’80 & ’82, which is what you had to do as a hard rock fan, but I’m glad I came around to their music by ’83. I completely agree with your Rocky IV assessment of that H2O cover. Nice to know we both like the other artwork featured here. They finally had some quality control.


  2. Daddydinorawk
    October 3, 2014

    Yeah, this stuff was popular at a time when I wasn’t really aware of different styles of music, (Born in ’73). The big radio station in the area played pretty much everything, so if it was on that station we listened to it. You could always hear some Hall and Oates tunes. i do own a copy of Rock and Soul. I think everyone liked No Can Do, Maneater, Kiss on My List and Private Eyes, etc. I never had any nothion of what was cool to listen to or not, still don’t. By 1985 I was an anomaly, stuck in a time warp. Of course thats for the next chapter. These songs are strong, the production values don’t seem dated today like the 70’s output, to my mind anyway.
    I gotta say I like the H20 cover. It’s not awful anyway.


    • You were definitely in the right age group to not be turned off by these recordings. All you knew was that they’re catchy songs, right? As for the production values, they’re definitely tied to the early-’80s but they still sound timeless. The same can’t be said of the next couple of albums, which I’m currently listening to in preparation for Part 4 of this series. The mid- to late-’80s might be the most plastic-sounding era in music history. Some artists pulled it off while others suffered from albums that will always be trapped in that period. It’s a shame because there are some wonderful songs trapped under too many layers of studio trickery.

      I agree that the H2O cover isn’t awful, but it’s a little unnecessarily homoerotic. Then again, as Ian pointed out in an earlier comment, they could have been mimicking the ’80s Rocky movies. I think the Private Eyes cover might be the best artwork of their career.


      • Daddydinorawk
        October 7, 2014

        Oh sure, you can look at the period from about 81-85 the widespread use of digital as a recording medium. Some very sterile sounding albums (Under Wraps, 90125 and Genesis S/T I’m looking at you-3 of my faves btw). H&O avoided that for the most part, the recordings from this period being somewhat warm.

        Hey between Oates and Freddie Mercury who had the better ‘tache? Anyway, anyone remember this one?


      • Great points about those other albums and their clear connection to the time they were recorded. In the end, good songs, good singing & good musicianship should be able to shine through questionable production choices.

        Thanks so much for sharing that Chariot Of Eggs sketch from SCTV. I had never seen it before and it’s hilarious. Also, H&O kicked serious ass in their performance of “Did It In A Minute,” and they weren’t bad actors either.

        As for the ‘stache contest, I think Oates wins in a landslide, especially because he’s had it for just about their entire career, while Freddy was clean-shaven with long hair until The Game in 1980.


  3. 1537
    October 3, 2014

    Man – that moustache!


  4. keepsmealive
    October 6, 2014

    Hey there! We’ve nominated you for a One Lovely Blog Award because your blog is awesome!

    As stated in the post, you can participate or not, it’s entirely up to you. It’s just a pleasure for us to give a nod to all the awesome blogs we read!


    Cheers, Aaron and James of the KMA


    • Thanks for the nomination, A&J. Due to a tight schedule I won’t be able to participate but I really appreciate the consideration. I will be sure to check out all of the other nominated blogs that I wasn’t previously familiar with.



      • keepsmealive
        October 7, 2014

        No problem Rich! We’re happy to tell everyone about your site!


  5. Chuck Hunnefield
    November 5, 2014

    H&O were a huge inspiration to me in the creation of my own music. Who would’ve thought that purposely using a cheap drum machine could make such a signature and compelling sound?! I recently heard ‘Time’s Up’ for the first time – don’t know how I missed it – and it, more than anything, really foreshadows the direction they were going in ‘Voices’.

    I’ve seen these guys live 6 times now, and you get what you pay for. No vocal correction boxes. No canned stuff. All live and real.


    • Hi Chuck. Thanks for stopping by. It’s always great to hear from another H&O fan, especially someone who’s been directly influenced by them as a musician. I’m glad you agree about the excellence of “Time’s Up.” What a shame that it’s only a CD bonus track. Had they included it on Voices it would be much more highly regarded.

      Nice to hear that you’ve seen them live 6 times. Sadly, I never did. I had hoped to see them on the Change Of Season tour but didn’t know any other H&O fans at the time. They’re still good now and I’d like to see them at some point, but it would have been great to see them during their prime years.


  6. Pingback: KamerTunesBlog Year In Review 2014 | KamerTunesBlog

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Enter your email address to subscribe to KamerTunesBlog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 569 other subscribers


%d bloggers like this: