Revisiting my extensive music collection, one artist at a time

THE BAND Part 5 – Waltzing In The Basement With Bob / In Conclusion

Between June and October 1967, Bob Dylan and The Band wrote & recorded dozens of songs in a home in West Saugerties, New York that was known as “Big Pink” (as in The Band’s debut album, Music From Big Pink). A number of these songs initially saw the light of day in 1969 on the unauthorized Bob Dylan record Great White Wonder, often cited as the first-ever bootleg album. Although not all of the songs on this bootleg were from the sessions with The Band, those are the ones that gained notoriety among fans and fellow musicians, and sealed the reputations of Rick Danko, Levon Helm, Garth Hudson, Richard Manuel and Robbie Robertson.

When Columbia released the 2-LP The Basement Tapes (1975), Dylan was experiencing a career resurgence with Blood On The Tracks (released earlier that year), while The Band was less than a year away from its big farewell. I’ve listened to The Basement Tapes a number of times over the years, and it always sounded like a collection of half-finished sketches, joke songs and throwaways. I’ve been a pretty big Dylan fan for a number of years (although I hope to revisit his voluminous catalog here in the future, as there are many albums I don’t know very well), so I always listened to this album more as a Dylan fan. Now that I’m much more familiar with The Band’s catalog and their individual contributions (vocally and instrumentally), I was able to enjoy it on a whole new level.

There are a couple of disclaimers about this album that I wasn’t previously aware of. First, Dylan is only on 16 of the 24 songs included. Also, there’s some dispute about the recording locations and dates. Apparently, some of the songs were recorded solely by The Band a year or two after the Dylan sessions, and some overdubs were added to existing recordings in 1975. While this makes The Basement Tapes less authentic to a purist, it still holds up really well…but it does come across more as a collection of songs than a cohesive album. I could go on to list things I like about almost every song, but instead I’ll just mention some of the highlights.

“Odds And Ends,” the first track, sounds like a loose tossed-off jam with a catchy chorus. It could also be a statement of intent for the hodgepodge nature of the album. “Million Dollar Bash” and “Lo And Behold!” would also fall into the category of loose & fun Dylan songs. I really like the way Danko & Manuel support Dylan during the choruses on these two. “Yazoo Street Scandal” is an anomaly, not sounding like anything by either of these artists. In fact it reminds me of some of the more experimental songs Paul McCartney recorded for his early solo albums, where his voice and instruments sounded slightly distorted. It took me a few listens to figure out it was Helm singing here.

The Basement Tapes – LP Gatefold Sleeve

A song that could’ve easily fit on The Band’s early albums is “Katie’s Been Gone,” featuring Manuel and Danko on harmonized lead vocals. This is one of the highlights of the album for me. I like “Bessie Smith,” but it sounds like it was recorded in the ‘70s (around Stage Fright or Cahoots), so sonically it doesn’t fit with most of the other songs here. The version of “Tears Of Rage,” with Dylan on vocals, didn’t have the same impact on me as the version from The Band’s debut album. It’s still a powerful song, but Manuel’s vocals added a special element that’s missing here. I enjoyed the weird and offbeat “Yea! Heavy And A Bottle Of Bread.” I have no idea what they’re singing about, but the chorus seeped into my brain on repeated listening, as did the neat little piano melody throughout the verses.

The old prison work song, “Ain’t No More Cane,” is a truly great Band song, with each vocalist (even Robertson) contributing a verse. Dylan wrote “Don’t Ya Tell Henry” although he’s not on the version here. It sounds like it was tailor-made for Helm’s twangy vocals. Another future Band song that doesn’t come across as powerfully with Dylan on vocals is “This Wheel’s On Fire.” I’d rather listen to the version from Music From Big Pink, but this is still a good way to close out this album. A few other standout tracks were “Please Mrs. Henry,” “Apple Suckling Tree,” “You Ain’t Goin’ Nowhere” (later recorded by The Byrds) and “Nothing Was Delivered.” I’m pleasantly surprised by how much I enjoyed The Basement Tapes after finally spending some time with it. I will revisit this album frequently in the future.

In 1976, The Band decided to stop touring (although based on some of the things I’ve read, this was more Robertson’s decision, which might indicate why the other members went back out on the road together in the early-80s). Instead of quietly fading into music history, Robertson collaborated with director Martin Scorsese to film their last concert, at San Francisco’s Winterland Ballroom, on Thanksgiving that year, and invited a number of talented guests to play with them. The resulting movie and soundtrack, The Last Waltz (1978), became both a historical document and an epitaph for a great band.

The original soundtrack album was a 3-record set, and it was eventually released on 2 CDs sometime in the late 1980’s. That’s the version I owned until Warner Bros./Rhino Records released a 4-CD box set version in 2002, which included over 20 previously unreleased recordings. In addition to well-executed Band classics like “Up On Cripple Creek,” “The Shape I’m In,” “The Weight,” “Stagefright” and “Acadian Driftwood,” they also acted as the house band for such diverse performers as their old leader, Ronnie Hawkins (a playful rendition of Bo Diddley’s “Who Do You Love”), Joni Mitchell (including some jazzy material, like “Shadows And Light”), Neil Young (sympathetic accompaniment on “Helpless” and “Four Strong Winds”), Van Morrison (an old traditional Irish song, as well as his own “Caravan”), Muddy Waters (the authentic blues of “Mannish Boy”), Emmylou Harris (the exquisite “Evangeline,” recorded not at the concert but on a soundstage at a later date), Bob Dylan (of course, and sounding strong on his five numbers), and several others. If nothing else, The Band proves that they can play almost anything, with the possible exception of jam-band improvisation (based on the previously unreleased “Jam #1” and “Jam #2,” which both go nowhere).

Neil Diamond, Joni Mitchell, Neil Young, Rick Danko, Van Morrison, Bob Dylan, Robbie Robertson and Ronnie Hawkins

I re-watched the movie a couple of days ago, and although it doesn’t include all of the performances from that night, for the most part they chose wisely. It’s very clear after watching it again that Robertson was in complete control, to the point where he obviously set himself up to be the star of the film. Sure, Helm and Danko get a lot of screen time, but Robertson seems to be highlighted more than the others. By this point, Manuel’s addictions had rendered him a shell of what he once was, so even though he sounds pretty good on his featured songs (“The Shape I’m In” and the duet with Van Morrison, especially), his ghostly visage remains mostly hidden in the background. Even Hudson, who contributes such amazing keyboard work, is mostly seen in the background or in silhouette. The newly written instrumental “Theme From The Last Waltz” is a touching end to the film, and the original album.

Over the years, The Last Waltz has gained a reputation as The Band’s definitive live album. This was an extra special night, and I’m glad it was filmed & recorded, but like the earlier live album Rock Of Ages, it doesn’t represent just the five original members on stage. This is a minor quibble, and every music fan should hear (or see) it at least once, just to understand the breadth of their abilities as musicians, singers, songwriters and accompanists.

Honorable mention should go to Before The Flood (1974), a 2-record live album documenting Bob Dylan and The Band on their 1974 tour. The sound quality is very good for its time, and the song selection leans more heavily toward Dylan but still features enough Band performances to make this a satisfying release for fans of both artists. Although I keep this CD with my Dylan collection, I decided to listen to it during my re-discovery of The Band, so I included it here. I’ve chosen to skip their 1974 studio collaboration, Planet Waves, as that was released as a Bob Dylan album. I’ll revisit it whenever I get around to tackling his catalog.

In conclusion, I’ve written so much about The Band these past few weeks, and there’s not much to add here. Revisiting their catalog has been such a revelation for me. I started out enjoying their music, and now I’m not just a fan…I LOVE this band. One day I may seek out the Complete Basement Tapes 5-CD bootleg, but for now I’m incredibly happy that I got to know their music so much better than I did before. These plastic discs in my collection are now alive with music that will continue to inspire me. I couldn’t ask for anything more.

Thanks for joining me on my continuing journey of re-discovery. Now it’s time to move on to my next artist. Check back soon.

7 comments on “THE BAND Part 5 – Waltzing In The Basement With Bob / In Conclusion

  1. Jon Lyness
    July 12, 2011

    Great stuff again, Rich!

    If you enjoy The Band’s catalog as much as it sounds like you did, it’s also worth tracking down some of the albums where they played with other great musicians. Probably my favorite example is Bobby Charles’ self-titled album from 1972, a period where The Band was largely on hiatus and found time to take on some side projects. The album is a real gem, with Bobby backed by a dream team of musicians (all of the Band members save Robbie, plus Dr. John, Amos Garrett, John Simon and more), and there’s some really sweet songs on there.

    (link to Amazon page with sound samples: http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00122RQDE/ref=pd_lpo_k2_dp_sr_1?pf_rd_p=486539851&pf_rd_s=lpo-top-stripe-1&pf_rd_t=201&pf_rd_i=B001BS4R9U&pf_rd_m=ATVPDKIKX0DER&pf_rd_r=04CGPPSX8790CJ4MVAZN )

    Really enjoyed your Band series, & look forward to future artists.

    Jon 🙂


    • KamerTunesBlog
      July 12, 2011

      Hi Jon. I’m glad you enjoyed the write-ups I did on The Band. I had such a great time listening to all those albums and getting to know them. Next time I revisit them will be a whole new experience. I appreciate you letting me know about those other albums, especially the Bobby Charles LP. I will definitely seek that out. Your input here has been greatly appreciated.



  2. Pingback: KamerTunesBlog Year In Review 2011 | KamerTunesBlog

  3. Tangled Up In Music (by Ovidiu Boar)
    April 18, 2015

    My favourite Basement Tapes song is ‘This Wheel’s on Fire’, which I like even more than the Band’s version, I think. Yes, The Band added all those neat instrumental touches and Danko’s paranoid voice is spot-on, but with Dylan it gives the feel of a slow, inevitable apocalypse coming which I think fits the lyrical theme more.

    On The Last Waltz I have mixed feelings. I enjoy most of the performances (the groove on the one with Dylan you posted is just fabulous!), but the scope of the whole thing doesn’t really feel right with me. It seems in a way to go against what the band stood and were famous for when they started out. Robbie is the star of the film and he does a good job at that, but The Band never had nor needed a star, you know? Manuel is obviously uncomfortable with the whole thing and I don’t blame him. For me the perfect goodbye from the Band would be a low-quality tape of them jamming and composing new songs in the Big Pink, nothing more.

    I love all your essays on The Band by the way and I’m glad I get the chance to talk about the band on an album-by-album basis.


    • Hi Ovidiu. Thanks for the comments about The Band. I wrote this series a few years ago and it remains one of my favorite discographies that I’ve revisited. I’ve recently been listening to the 6-CD Basement Tapes Complete box set and I’m appreciating the work they did with Dylan more than ever. I agree that “This Wheel’s On Fire” is a highlight of their collaboration, although I’m not sure which version I prefer. You make a great case for the Dylan version. Your thoughts on both versions are really insightful.

      I know what you mean about The Last Waltz. It’s too much of a “special event” for it to be truly indicative of a live Band performance, but I really enjoy it for what it is. It’s a shame that Manuel wasn’t in great shape at the time.

      Do you have a favorite album by The Band?


      • Tangled Up In Music (by Ovidiu Boar)
        April 20, 2015

        Hey, Rich. It’s either the first or the second, depending on the day, I guess. There’s only about 2 songs on each that I don’t *love*, just *like*, which is pretty much the highest compliment I can give to an album (only a few others are like that – Pet Sounds, Velvet Underground & Nico etc.). Today I’ll have to say The Band, because of the stunning King Harvest which sounds unlike anything I’ve ever heard before. What about you?


      • I agree that Music From Big Pink and The Band are pretty close to perfect, and it’s hard to choose a favorite, but I would have to give the nod to the second album since it’s a little more cohesive. I can think of a lot of albums that are filled mostly with songs I “love” rather than “like.” Perhaps that could be the subject of a series in the future. Thanks for the inspiration.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Enter your email address to subscribe to KamerTunesBlog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 570 other subscribers


%d bloggers like this: